26 April 2010
The Cost of Death: the Case of Brian Nichols
8:54 PM |
Posted by
Brady |
Edit Post
[The following is an article I wrote that was published in Boston University's Pre-Law Review Magazine,
Spring 2008 edition. The views herein expressed are my own.]
The death penalty is among the most controversial sentencing practices in the American criminal justice system. The United States remains one of few industrialized countries that employ the death penalty as a form of legal atonement. Testing the religious and moral values of the American public, the practice has been notoriously lengthy and costly. While debate over the issue will undoubtedly persist, recent developments in a flagrant, violent crime have had grave implications for supporters of death penalty jurisprudence.
On March 11, 2005, Brian Nichols, a 33 year old African American, appeared in court to face charges of rape and false imprisonment. Nichols’ previous trial for these offenses had resulted in a hung jury. While in the custody of the Fulton County Courthouse in Atlanta, Georgia, Nichols began a violent rampage that would result in the largest manhunt in Georgia’s history. While changing into street clothes to wear in court, he overpowered sheriff’s deputy Cynthia Hall and took her firearm. After attacking the deputy, he entered the private chambers of Judge Rowland W. Barnes, where he encountered another deputy and stole his gun. Nichols then entered a courtroom, shot Barnes in the back of the head, killed court stenographer Julie Ann Brandau, and shot Sergeant Hoyt Teasley, a pursuing officer.
After his escape, Nichols carjacked three vehicles at gunpoint and pistol-whipped a reporter. In search of a hiding place, he murdered federal agent David Wilhelm and kidnapped a woman, who later convinced him to surrender. Georgia authorities arrested him 24 hours later. He was indicted in May 2005 in the same courthouse in which many of the killings occurred months earlier, facing the additional charges of murder, kidnapping, robbery, aggravated assault on a police officer, battery, theft, carjacking, and escaping from authorities. District Attorney Paul L. Howard, Jr. sought the death penalty and the case was expected to cost nearly $5 million and to last up to seven months.
Nichols, a former UPS employee and regular churchgoer, devised an elaborate scheme to break out of an Atlanta jailhouse that involved his pen-pal girlfriend, a paralegal, and at least two sheriff’s deputies. The plot was discovered and foiled in October 2006 when Nichols was moved to another facility. The Nichols case gained further national media attention after it stalled almost three years later. During the pre-trial conference in September 2007, Nichols’ defense team, which had been paid $1.2 million for its services, announced that it was not receiving enough funding from Georgia’s public defender’s office. Superior Court Judge Hilton Fuller was forced to suspend the state trial during the jury selection process. Fuller warned that the case might be suspended indefinitely if the defense was not provided adequate funding. The state public defender’s office defied the judge’s order to continue funding the defense attorneys, arguing that it did not possess the necessary funds.
In November 2007, the district attorney appealed to Georgia’s Supreme Court to force Judge Fuller to commence the jury selection process. His request was denied, and the trial was delayed for the fifth time on November 16, 2007. On January 30, 2008, Fuller stepped down from the case after being quoted in The New Yorker magazine as saying, “Everyone in the world knows he did it.” He submitted his recusal to the chief justice of the superior court, noting his breach of impartiality.
In light of these recent, troubling events, the Nichols case raises serious questions about the effectiveness of the death penalty process, a system clearly overburdened. The Supreme Court ruled in Gideon v. Wainwright (1963) that impoverished defendants must be provided free legal counsel in order for proceedings to commence. However, the question of how much these public defenders should be paid and how to assign them remains up to the legal purview of individual states. The system in Georgia had been revised in 2005 and now includes the Georgia Capital Defenders Office, which provides indigent defendants with attorneys specifically trained in capital cases. The funds for these attorneys come from legal fees collected from plaintiffs, since taxpayers were disinclined to pay for expensive capital cases. This system is representative of other systems in states that still practice capital punishment.
In the case of Brian Nichols, the prosecution enjoyed the prospect of eye-witness testimony and a written confession to all four killings. This reality, uncommon in capital cases, has not guaranteed that his victims will be vindicated. The capital punishment system appears broken, with evidence-filled cases taking longer and costing the public more. This reality represents the failures of the capital punishment system and has repercussions that are hard to deny.
According to Amnesty International, 135 countries have abolished the death penalty. The United States remains one of few industrialized countries to permit it. The Nichols case serves as an example of a whimsical practice that is hard to vindicate. Supporters of capital punishment argue that it is the ultimate form of deterrence, incapacitation, and moral correctness. Yet, research by William Bowers of Northeastern University shows that the death penalty does not curtail violence. States that do not allow the death penalty tend to have lower murder rates than those that employ it. Former Texas Attorney General Jim Mattox has remarked, "It is my own experience that those executed in Texas were not deterred by the existence of the death penalty law. I think in most cases you'll find that the murder was committed under severe drug and alcohol abuse." According to a survey by former presidents of America’s top criminological societies, 84 percent of them admitted that research has not proven the death penalty is a deterrent to crime.
Aside from the debatable statistics and research, death penalty cases are extremely expensive. Defendants are afforded an array of additional rights and protections when preparing their defense, including character analysis by experts, psychiatrists, and psychologists. Juries in these cases are asked to consider much more than guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. They must account for factors such as mental illness or any aspect of the defendant’s character or record that may mitigate a lesser sentence. However, if the system is unable to function due to economic constraints, as evidence suggests, it should be abolished. If states are unable to derive the necessary funds, a miscarriage of justice becomes likely, such as in the case of Brian Nichols. If the district attorney had not sought the death penalty, Nichols may well be currently serving a life sentence in prison.
Based on the Brian Nichols case, as well as analysis of the cost-benefit factor, the death penalty is inefficient and ineffective. Legislators should move beyond the moral and religious debate and simply realize the economic constraints of the system. If states cannot provide public defenders with adequate pay, criminals win. In the case of Brian Nichols, he has won, as his case remains suspended until the situation is resolved. The reality of the death penalty in Georgia has shaken Americans’ trust and faith in the criminal justice system.
[The following material was not published.]
[The following material was not published.]
UPDATE: On December 13, 2008, Brian Nichols received multiple life sentences from a judge in Atlanta's Municipal Court. The Nichols case, originally docketed as a capital trial, cost the state of Georgia $3 million dollars. According to the Federal Bureau of Prisons, which compiles data for all 50 states and the District of Columbia, the average annual cost of housing an inmate per year is $25,000. Confining Brian Nichols for 40 years would still not equal the $3 million spent by Georgia to achieve a sentence. Moreover, the prosectors failed to persuade the jury to sentence him to death. If the jury had obliged, the Nichols saga would have continued through the complicated death row appellate process, which would have cost taxpayers even more money.
I do not intend this post to begin a debate over whether or not the death penalty is morally justifiable. Frankly, I believe in some instances it is preferable. Rather, we need to examine the issue from an economic and deterrence standpoint. We need to establish a more concrete connection between capital punishment and deterrence. If such a connection cannot be found, we cannot rely on that argument for justifying the death penalty. Moreover, if the system we employ to convict criminals in capital cases ends up costing us more than housing an inmate for 40 years or more (nearly life), clearly it needs to be revised. Since capital punishment remains a state power, the states are burdened with paying for the cost of the proceedings. If we as a nation insist on retaining this most-antiquated practice, we should at least update the legal process it relies upon.
Assuming that states will never cede this power to the federal government, there are two methods for improving the system that stand out to me:
1.) State and local legislators might need to remove some of the safeguards in the system, particularly at the appellate level, to keep costs down and expedite the process.
2.) Taxpayers will have to foot more of the bill in order to prevent 4 year trials that cost millions of dollars.
I do not intend this post to begin a debate over whether or not the death penalty is morally justifiable. Frankly, I believe in some instances it is preferable. Rather, we need to examine the issue from an economic and deterrence standpoint. We need to establish a more concrete connection between capital punishment and deterrence. If such a connection cannot be found, we cannot rely on that argument for justifying the death penalty. Moreover, if the system we employ to convict criminals in capital cases ends up costing us more than housing an inmate for 40 years or more (nearly life), clearly it needs to be revised. Since capital punishment remains a state power, the states are burdened with paying for the cost of the proceedings. If we as a nation insist on retaining this most-antiquated practice, we should at least update the legal process it relies upon.
Assuming that states will never cede this power to the federal government, there are two methods for improving the system that stand out to me:
1.) State and local legislators might need to remove some of the safeguards in the system, particularly at the appellate level, to keep costs down and expedite the process.
2.) Taxpayers will have to foot more of the bill in order to prevent 4 year trials that cost millions of dollars.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
CNN.com
About Me
- Brady
- I am a graduate of Boston University. I majored in political science and minored in history.
My Facebook
My Tweets
Blogroll
-
-
In 2024 Senate Races, Democrats Hope for Record in Electing Black Women - With Vice President Kamala Harris at the top of the ticket and Senate seats open, Democrats could for the first time send two Black women to the chamber.1 hour ago
-
‘War on Drugs 2.0’: Gavin Newsom's play against a crimefighting initiative - The California campaign to defeat Proposition 36 is hoping voters see the ballot initiative as a return to a hard line on drug enforcement.1 hour ago
-
Byron Scott Changes Tune On JJ Redick After Assistant Coaching Hires - Byron Scott is feeling MUCH better about JJ Redick leading the Lakers ... telling TMZ Sports he's more confident in his chances at success after bringing i...2 hours ago
-
NYT's The Mini crossword answers for September 16 - Answers to each clue for the September 16, 2024 edition of NYT's The Mini crossword puzzle.2 hours ago
-
J.K. Dobbins makes team history in vaulting Chargers to 2-0 start - Jim Harbaugh promised to run the ball, and Dobbins has delivered on that strategy.3 hours ago
-
How to Beat ‘Unhuman’ Communists At Their Own Game - Photo Credit:Unhumans, the Jack Posobiec book cover on a tweet twitter screenshot Communism thrives on resentment, vengeance, and terror. Its weapon is...6 hours ago
-
‘Appalling And Indefensible’: Elon Musk Incites Rage Online After Claiming No One Is ‘Trying to Assassinate Biden/Kamala’ - Billionaire Elon Musk sent out a controversial post on Sunday following the attempted assassination on former President Donald Trump. The post ‘Appalling ...7 hours ago
-
A plastic Apple Watch SE may still be happening, but not until next year - Apple announced a bunch of new products at the It’s Glowtime event on Sept. 9, but the rumored Apple Watch SE with a plastic shell wasn’t among them. Tha...13 hours ago
-
The Forest Hills, Shelley Duvall’s Final Film, Gets a Bloody Trailer - [image: The Forest Hills] The indie horror film featuring Duvall's last, posthumous performance hits theaters and streaming in October.14 hours ago
-
-
IRS Whistleblowers Sue Hunter Biden’s Lawyer Abbe Lowell for Defamation - Last January, I received a letter threatening me with a defamation lawsuit if I continued my criticism of Hunter Biden,…1 day ago
-
REVIEW / JustAxe (PC) - That VideoGame Blog REVIEW / JustAxe (PC) JustAxe reminds me of an Adobe Flash game back in the Newgrounds/Kongregate days of yore. The post REVIEW / Ju...1 day ago
-
The Misguided Antitrust Investigations in AI - The eagerness of antitrust enforcement in such an emerging market is just the latest example of the “big is bad” mentality that drives much of the US’ curr...2 days ago
-
The morning read for Friday, Sept. 13 - [image: The morning read for Friday, Sept. 13]Each weekday, we select a short list of news articles, commentary, and other noteworthy links related to th...2 days ago
-
OKC's Sam Presti is an overrated draft savant - Sam Presti is the only NBA executive ever to draft three future MVPs and he did it in three consecutive drafts. It’s a maniacal stroke of luck and an exe...6 months ago
-
What Americans Think Of The Biden Impeachment Inquiry - Welcome to Pollapalooza, our weekly-ish polling roundup. It’s officially impeachment season again. On Tuesday, House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy announc...1 year ago
-
'-30-': An Ending, But Not the End, by Michelle Malkin - When I first started writing newspaper editorials and columns for the Los Angeles Daily News in November 1992, I learned that "-30-" (pronounced "dash thir...1 year ago
-
Bop Shop: Songs From Doechii, Sunmi, The Beths, And More - This week's Bop Shop includes a mix of songs by Doechii, Sunmi, Chung Ha, Broadside, The Beths, and more.2 years ago
-
Hocus Pocus 2 Resurrects The Sanderson Sisters For A New Generation - The Sanderson sisters are back for revenge! Watch the spooky teaser trailer for 'Hocus Pocus 2.'2 years ago
-
Listen to This: The Race To Ban Abortion - A new episode of The Josh Marshall Podcast is live! This week, Kate and guest host Nicole Lafond discuss the...2 years ago
-
-
Call for Papers: Fourth Annual Regional Health Law Works-in-Progress Retreat - Seton Hall Law School’s Center for Health & Pharmaceutical Law & Policy is pleased to announce the Fourth Annual Regional Health Law Works-in-Progress Retr...5 years ago
-
Dem Rep Speier: School Shooting Focus on Mental Illness ‘Fundamentally Ignorant’ - [image: Mass Shooters] Democrat Congresswoman calls focusing on mental health to help stop school shootings as "fundamentally ignorant."6 years ago
-
President Donald J. Trump's Year of Regulatory Reform and Environmental Protection at the EPA - *“We’re ending intrusive EPA regulations that kill jobs, hurt family farmers and ranchers, and raise the price of energy so quickly and so substantially....6 years ago
-
-
-
Facebook post – UK’s Prime Minister Theresa May – about Nice - “I am shocked and saddened by the horrifying attack in Nice last night. Our hearts go out to the French people and to all those who’ve lost loved ones or b...8 years ago
-
Breaking Down Barriers in Sexual and Reproductive Health Reporting in Africa - *This is a guest post by Humphrey Nabimanya, founder of Reach a Hand Uganda. * [image: 2016-04-15-1460736651-1435623-huffpo1.jpg]*Journalists and bloggers...8 years ago
-
Mom Has Stacked Dinner Party Roster - GOLDEN, CO—Their eyes widening in amazement as the 43-year-old rattled off the names of heavy hitter after heavy hitter, impressed members of the Dreesh...8 years ago
-
Republicans are a lot closer to ‘maybe Trump’ than ‘never Trump’ - [image: Republicans are a lot closer to 'maybe Trump' than 'never Trump'] The goal of the nebulous, sort-of-a-thing "never Trump" campaign is to do whate...8 years ago
-
The search for the best middle-class tax cut - Say you want to help struggling middle-class families by cutting their taxes. Say you want to figure out an actually helpful plan to do that, and not just ...8 years ago
-
It Is Accomplished - As Gandhi never quite said, First they ignore you. Then they laugh at you. Then they attack you. Then you win. I remember one of the first TV debates I had...9 years ago
-
The Greatest eBay Sales Pitches Ever - At the outset let me point out that there’s very little I can add to either of these authentic stream-of-conciousness sagas of Hall of Famer Eddie Mathews,...11 years ago
-
MB4 – “You Can’t See Me” - Marshall Brennan releases his first visuals to his “ButtonUp Music” & “Sky Living” campaign as he pumps out some lyrical heat with “You Can’t See Me.” Pro...13 years ago
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
0 comments:
Post a Comment